Skip to content
Published Nov 12, 202615 minutes readingLatest

Capped and bypassed: how interchange caps and instant payments are changing bank loyalty

Next Stop: Banking Loyalty · Stop 1 · São Paulo

Follow us:
Capped and bypassed: how interchange caps and
instant payments are changing bank loyalty

Cards still grow, but two forces are changing what they are worth: regulators capped what the card earns, and instant rails took the everyday payment. That changes what a bank should reward.

Mateusz Figiel · October 2026

São Paulo starts early. Long before the glass towers on Avenida Paulista and Faria Lima, where many of Brazil's banks keep their offices, switch on the lights, the neighborhood padarias are full. A ‘média’ (the classic São Paulo coffee with milk), a slice of ‘pão na chapa’ (a crusty roll pressed with butter on a hot flat-top griddle), and a phone held over a QR code on the counter. No card anywhere.

R$36. That is the median Pix payment in Brazil in 2025, about USD 7: a coffee and buttered toast, a pharmacy run, a lunch near the office. In 2020, payments from people to businesses were 6% of all Pix transactions. By 2025, they were 43%.

Every one of those payments is a daily moment between a bank and its customer, and a card-only loyalty program sees none of them.

São Paulo is also the city of the traffic jam, so its people know how to go around one. The debit card found itself in a jam of its own: Brazil's central bank capped what debit earns, and Pix gave customers another route. That is why this is the first stop of our banking loyalty series: two forces hit the same card, and the bakery counter is where you see the result.

Postcard from São Paulo

Postcard from São Paulo

Local rails

Pix and the debit interchange cap

The number

Pix accounted for 54.7% of all payment transactions in the second half of 2025, against 30.4% for all cards combined (BCB)

What this stop teaches us

When the regulator takes the margin and the rail takes the habit, debit stalls and rewards move to credit

How card rewards became the center of bank loyalty programs

For seventy years, bank loyalty had one center of gravity, and it was made of plastic.

In 1950, Diners Club let restaurant guests pay later. In 1981, American Airlines launched AAdvantage, and the idea of earning something for every dollar spent traveled fast, from airlines to card issuers.

The economics were simple. Every card payment carries an interchange fee, paid by the merchant's side to the issuer. Part of it went back to the cardholder as points, miles, or cashback. The merchant paid, the bank distributed, and the customer collected. The program was a card program because the money came from the card.

That's mostly a North American story. Europe met the first half of the problem a decade ago, when the 2015 interchange cap pushed banks to look for program funding beyond card fees. What's new, everywhere, is the second half: the payments a program could still reward are moving to rails it doesn't listen to.

Yet the habit survived. In many banks, program design still starts from the card portfolio, and the loyalty team still sits next to the cards team. Now that habit is under pressure from two sides at once.

Two forces shrinking card-based bank loyalty

The first force takes away the money: regulators cap interchange. The second takes away the visibility: instant rails move everyday payments outside the card.

Cards aren't dying. Card spend still grows in most markets: cards win on value, the large tickets, and still rule cross-border payments, because instant rails remain mostly domestic. Instant rails win on frequency, the small payments of everyday life. The two forces also travel at different speeds. The first is global. The second is already decisive in Brazil, India, and Poland (as exemplary markets), early in the euro area, and largely absent from US retail.

Wherever it arrives, though, cards lose the same payment: debit, the everyday purchase made from the customer's own money. That's exactly the payment that gave the bank its daily contact with the customer.

For the loyalty owner, the problem is share, not volume. In Brazil, Pix handled 79.8 billion transactions in 2025, 3.7 times as many as credit cards. A program that rewards only card spend rewards a shrinking share of the customer’s payments by count.

Why interchange caps shrink the money behind card rewards

Start where we stand. Brazil caps debit and prepaid and leaves credit uncapped, and that is where the money went: in 2025, credit card spend grew 14.5%, while debit grew 0.2%. The same script has played out elsewhere: debit gets the hardest cap, credit a softer one or none.

Market

Debit

Credit

Other

Brazil

0.5%

No cap

Prepaid 0.7% (BCB)

EU

0.2%

0.3%

Non-EEA cards online: 1.15% debit, 1.5% credit (IFR; European Commission)

United States

21¢ + 0.05%

No cap

Issuers under USD 10bn exempt (Regulation II)

Australia

8¢ or 0.16%

0.3% consumer

Commercial credit 0.8%; foreign cards 1.0% (RBA)

On a EUR 50 basket, EU debit interchange comes to 10 cents: a thank-you, and very little else. In the United States, an appeals court sent the debit rule back to the Federal Reserve to rewrite in October 2026, and the current cap stays until the ruling takes effect. Australia's new caps started in October 2026, with foreign cards following in April 2027, and its central bank expects merchants to save about AUD 910 million a year.

The consequence for loyalty is direct. Rewards migrate to where interchange is still rich, in credit and premium cards, and the everyday debit customer gets less and less. In the United States, about half of the regulated issuers with a debit rewards program ended it within a year of the 2011 cap. Debit rewards have since returned only where the cap does not apply: small issuers, exempt from the limit, partnering with brands and fintechs. Regulation didn't kill the card program. It turned it into a program for the few.

Only cross-border online payments keep the old economics. A non-European credit card paying online in Europe can still earn up to 1.5% interchange, under voluntary caps extended to November 2029. That funds travel cards, not everyday loyalty.

How instant payments move everyday spending away from debit cards

Instant rails are account-to-account systems that move money between accounts in seconds. Add a QR code or a proxy identifier—like a phone number, email, or ID—and they become a way to pay in a shop.

Number

What it is

Source

+0.2%

Debit card spend growth, Brazil, 2025

Abecs

43%

Share of Pix transactions paid by people to businesses, 2025, up from 6% in 2020

Banco Central do Brasil

84%

UPI's share of India's digital payments by number, FY2025-26

Ministry of Finance

756m

BLIK transactions in Poland, Q1 2026, up 14% YoY

Polski Standard Płatności

Back to the padaria counter. Brazil is the clearest case anywhere: the regulator squeezed debit, Pix took its visibility, and credit, which has no cap, kept growing. Most Pix payments are small, and these high-frequency moments are what create daily contact with a customer. They have left the debit card.

India tells the same story, with a twist. UPI makes 84% of the country's digital payments by number, mostly to merchants, while credit cards keep the big tickets. As Worldline puts it, UPI owns frequency, credit owns value.

Europe is two markets. In Poland, BLIK has overtaken cards online and is now reaching the till, with 172 million in-store payments in the first quarter of 2026 alone, almost half of them contactless. In the euro area, the card's main rival at the till is still cash, used in 52% of point-of-sale transactions (ECB, 2024). A challenger is on its way, though. Wero, a bank-owned wallet that pays account to account, already handles transfers and online payments, and shops are next.

The United States is the exception. RTP (Real-Time Payments, run by The Clearing House) and the Federal Reserve's FedNow mostly move payouts and business payments, rather than groceries, because Americans already have digital payments that feel instant (Richmond Fed).

Different speeds, same question: what should a bank reward when the card no longer sees the everyday payment?

What a bank loyalty program should reward beyond card spend

Reward the relationship beyond the swipe

The strongest signal of a primary bank is where the salary lands and the savings sit. Many banks already use it in pricing, as fee waivers for salaried customers, but pricing is invisible and binary. A loyalty layer turns the same condition into a journey the customer can see and climb.

Research on app engagement supports the mechanic: in a Journal of Marketing Research study of almost 19,000 users of a gamified app, game rewards lifted engagement beyond what value rewards achieved, most strongly when users were close to a reward.

For example, Nubank, based in São Paulo, launched Nubank Croma in July 2026. Its R$39 monthly fee is waived for customers who spend R$4,000 a month on the credit card or keep R$30,000 invested or saved with the bank, so one of the two routes in has nothing to do with card spend.

Reward behavior

Some of the most valuable habits never touch a card: saving regularly, paying on time, and keeping a buffer. A program that rewards these habits recognizes the customer the bank most wants to keep, whether or not they ever reach for a card.

Listen to every rail the bank already sees

A bank already sees every instant payment from its own accounts, but that data sits in core banking while the loyalty engine listens to the card processor. Connect the two, and reward sustained behavior, such as a savings order kept for three months, rather than individual transfers, which invite abuse.

For example, in Brazil, a card-only program misses more than half of all payments, most of them passing through the bank's own systems.

Anchor benefits on the member, rather than the card number

When a lounge visit belongs to the tier instead of the card product, a mortgage customer or a wealth client can earn it too. Few traditional banks do this at scale yet, and someone must fund each visit, through tier economics or the member's own points.

Let merchants pay

With interchange capped, merchants become the funder, paying to reach the right customers.

For example, JPMorgan Chase launched Chase Media Solutions in April 2024, letting brands target its 80 million customers, and eMarketer expects US financial media ad spend to nearly double, to USD 1.22 billion in 2026. Most banks lack Chase's scale, which is why aggregated merchant supply matters.

How banks can fund loyalty rewards as interchange shrinks

Rewarding instant payments earns the bank almost nothing directly. Brazil's central bank keeps Pix low cost for consumers, and India has said it doesn't plan to charge for UPI. So the money has to come from three places.

  • The relationship itself. A salary account brings stable deposits that the bank lends at a margin, and a customer who banks here first is easier to sell a loan or insurance to. Long-term financing is especially powerful here: holding long-term debt, like a mortgage or auto loan, creates enduring loyalty that anchors the customer to the institution for years, if not decades. Part of that long-term relationship creates a lifetime value that easily funds the rewards.
  • Merchants. A brand funds the cashback, plus a fee, only when a targeted offer turns into a purchase. The bank passes the reward to the customer and keeps the fee.
  • Subscriptions. The customer pays a monthly fee for a tier of benefits, and the fee covers their cost. Revolut's subscription revenue grew 67% to USD 936 million in 2025.

Illustrative: twenty debit payments of EUR 50 each earn the issuer EUR 2 a month at the EU cap, or EUR 24 a year. A salary account holding EUR 3,000 at a 2% margin earns the bank EUR 60 a year, plus the loan or insurance it helps sell. The reward can cost up to that, but only for salaries that would not have moved anyway, so test it against a control group.

How Comarch Loyalty builds loyalty around the whole banking relationship

We build loyalty around the customer, rather than around the card. One platform, plus the services to put it in place, answers every move above, following the whole relationship instead of one product or one slice of a customer's financial life. Nedbank's Greenbacks program runs on it. After the relaunch, the bank reported 25% more engagement in earning points and 20% more members, and members now hold more products.

The platform

  • One member, the whole relationship. The member is the system of record. The card is one attribute next to salary, deposits, loans, and insurance, so a customer who moves their salary in is recognized the same day.
  • Status on everything the customer does. Tiers rest on balances, salary, tenure, products, and repayment, with card spend as one input, so a mortgage customer and a card customer climb the same ladder.
  • Every rail is an event source. Card messages, core banking events, and instant payments arrive in one stream, with abuse controls at the point of earning.
  • The bank owns the currency and the entitlements. Benefits go to the profile through partner APIs, with no card number in the flow. The bank's own points ledger makes "pay with points" possible, which no benefit provider can deliver alone.
  • Many suppliers, one decision maker. Aggregators bring merchant-funded inventory. Targeting, measurement, and consent checks stay with the bank, as guidelines require for marketing on payment data.
  • One program, every channel. The same member view and benefits show up in the app, branches, contact center, and partner touchpoints.
  • The bank and its partners on one ledger. Airlines, retailers, and insurers earn and burn on the same profile, so the program follows the customer through everyday life.
  • Reporting that keeps the books under control.Dashboards track redemption value and flagged transactions, so finance can forecast program costs.

The services

  • Discovery. We start with the bank's needs, infrastructure, and technology capabilities, beginning with which rails the program sees today.
  • Build and run. We connect the platform to core banking, the card processor, and the instant rails, migrate the existing program without losing what members have earned, and run it.

In most banks, this does not require a new core system. It requires the loyalty layer to stop being a card accessory and start listening to the whole relationship. That view is also what AI needs: churn, next-best-offer, and fraud models act only on what the program sees.

Three questions to test your bank loyalty program

  1. What share of your customers' monthly payments can your program actually see today?
  2. If the debit card disappeared from a customer's wallet tomorrow, what would your program still reward?
  3. Is your most valuable benefit attached to a card product, or to the customer?

If the answers feel uncomfortable, you're in good company. Most programs were designed for a world where these questions were easy.

The card remains a very good product, and it will keep growing. It just isn't the program anymore.

Sent from São Paulo

São Paulo shows the rest of the world what happens when an instant rail reaches the till. The card survives, even thrives, while the everyday moments that build loyalty quietly move somewhere else. Brazil got there first. Poland is close behind, and the euro area is next in line.

Next stop: Brussels, where the rules that rewrote your program are written.

Sources

Regulation

Market data 2024–2026

Programs, companies, and research